A judge has again found that Cookeville Boat Dock must pay delinquent DeKalb County property taxes, but in a new ruling Judge Amy Hollars has granted a motion by the marina’s attorney to bar the county from collecting more than 10 years in back taxes with 10 years being a statue of limitations. That ruling saves the boat dock nearly $60,000. However, the judge ruled against the boat dock when it came to the amount of interest the county could charge on the back taxes.
Judge Hollars announced her decision via a telephone conference call Tuesday morning with Vester Parsley, Jr., the county’s tax attorney, and Jon Jones of Cookeville, the lawyer representing Cookeville Boat Dock. Clerk and Master Deborah Malone and County Mayor Tim Stribling were also present.
The boat dock owners have refused to pay their taxes since 1998. As of Tuesday, the total amount owed comes to $204,504 including taxes, interest, penalty, court costs, and attorneys fees. As a result of the judge’s decision, the boat dock will NOW owe the county only $136,051 for the delinquency from 2004-2013
Jones initially argued for the marina that Tennessee law violated the Supremacy Clause of the U.S. Constitution by discriminating against a lessee of the United States in favor of lessees of the State of Tennessee. It was argued since the boat dock pays fees to the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers which are used, in part, to pay DeKalb County a sum of “in lieu of taxes,”that having to pay property tax to the county was, in effect, double taxation.
In April Judge Hollers ruled that the boat dock’s challenge to the tax was invalid in part because the Supremacy Clause “does not prevent a state or local government from imposing a tax on an individual or a corporation ‘using government property in connection with a business conducted for its own private gain.”
The attorney for the marina later filed a motion asking the judge to reconsider her ruling. Jones argued that the county cannot collect taxes beyond 10 years; that the judge’s ruling on the “Supremacy Clause” of the U.S. Constitution was incorrect; and that the amount of interest the county wants to charge is above what is allowed by law.
In the motion for “additional consideration of issues,” attorney Jones pointed to a Tennessee law that states, “All taxes assessed against real property and personal property in this state shall be barred, discharged and uncollectible after the lapse of 10 years from April 1 of the year following the year in which such taxes become delinquent, whether suit be brought within that time or not to collect the taxes.”
Judge Hollars sustained Jones’ motion on the 10 year bar based on TCA 67-5-1806. ” Here it’s not an action for recovery. There has been no payment under protest or otherwise. We do not have an action that is or has been before an administrative appeal before the state board of equalization so I think I have to rule that the 10 year bar does apply here so Cookeville Boat Dock will be relieved of several years of their taxes,” said Judge Hollars.
As for the interest issue, the defendants argued “prejudgment interest may be awarded by courts or juries in accordance with the principles of equity at any rate not in excess of a maximum effective rate of 10 percent per annum.”
The motion stated that the county “had not provided a breakdown regarding its proposed computation of prejudgment interest. However, defendant (boat dock) expected the county would claim prejudgment interest at a rate of 18 percent per annum. This exceeded the maximum rate of prejudgment interest this court is allowed to award.”
The defendant went on to suggest the interest rate “should correspond with the interest rate DeKalb County has paid during the relevant time.”
Showing documentation the county borrowed money or issued bonds in recent years at rates varying from one to 5.5 percent, the defendant claimed “these rates should provide the upper limit on an award of prejudgment interest that the court may make in this case.”
While Judge Hollars granted the motion to bar the county from collecting delinquent taxes beyond 10 years, she denied the request to prohibit the county from assessing the current rate of interest and penalty. “Because this is a case involving the taxes, I think the more specific statute TCA 67-5-2010 controls as to the amount of interest that is applicable. That calls for interest of one percent which shall be added on March 1 following the tax due date. That defines the specific rule with regard to the amount of interest applicable to these taxes. There is an additional one half of one percent that goes into that figuring and there is an additional penalty when suit is filed to enforce a tax lien that is set forth in TCA 67-5-2410,” Judge Hollars said.
She also affirmed her earlier ruling on the constitutionality of the tax. “I’m not going to disturb my previous ruling with regard to Article II Section 28 and the asserted constitutionality of it,” Judge Hollars concluded.
Mary Ellen Knack of Nashville has been representing the state on behalf of the Tennessee Attorney General’s Office in this case as to the
constitutionality of issues being challenged by the marina. Knack was not present for the telephone conference.
Both sides have thirty days to file an appeal from the date the court’s order is entered.

Getting children excited about science, technology, engineering and math, STEM subjects can be a challenge for any teacher. Yet some of the teachers at DeKalb Middle School will have a new tool to ignite their students’ interest, the STEMmobile.
The STEMmobile is a mobile learning laboratory that provides a unique, on-site educational experience for pre-kindergarten through eighth-grade school children in 20 Tennessee counties, including DeKalb County. This mobile classroom brings much needed technology to the doorsteps of schools, and the students have access to state-of-the-art equipment to help them to learn about STEM topics in creative and hands-on ways.
DeKalb Middle School will be hosting a community/parent night on Thursday, December 3 from 5:00 p.m. until 7:00 p.m.
The STEMmobile is a one-of-a-kind product of the Oakley STEM Center and Tennessee Tech University as part of the Upper Cumberland Rural STEM Initiative, a grant project funded by Tennessee’s First to the Top program. UCRSI is part of the Tennessee STEM Innovation Network, whose mission is to enhance student participation and interest in STEM subjects.
The UCRSI project includes STEM platform schools in Putnam County and a hub school selected by each participating county or school district to become more focused on STEM learning. UCRSI also has a STEM Hub, the Oakley STEM Center at Tennessee Tech University in Cookeville. The
UCRSI Hub represents a partnership between the 21 school districts, three post-secondary institutions and 11 STEM-related or innovative businesses and non-profit organizations committed to supporting STEM education.
UCRSI’s goal is to tackle the unique challenges of enhancing STEM education for younger learners in mostly rural areas, and to create innovative and collaborative solutions to these challenges. Some might say doing that requires thinking outside the box. In this case, UCRSI decided the perfect solution was to re-envision what a box could do.
Housed in a 53-foot tractor-trailer with self-contained power, the STEMmobile has its own heating and cooling system, a satellite uplink for Internet connectivity and workstations to accommodate about 24 students at a time. The classroom on wheels is stocked with equipment from the Oakley STEM Center and includes equipment and supplies for activities for each grade level.
The Oakley STEM Center also has a lending library of STEM instructional materials to partially equip the STEMmobile and classroom kits for STEM subjects are on board, ready to go.
The STEMmobile is designed to help students learn more about three core STEM themes particularly relevant to rural students: water, with a focus on its importance, usage and conservation; energy, which highlights how power is generated, ways to lower consumption, green energy and long-term energy needs; and my food, my body, my health, which helps students learn more about agriculture, health, nutrition and physical fitness.
Science teachers from DeKalb Middle Middle School, Nancy Cowan. Justin Poteete, Cassandra Binkley and Suzette Barnes were recently trained to use the learning studio at the Oakley STEM Center so they are ready to make the most of the STEMmobile.
For more information about the STEMmobile, please go to www.ucrsi.org or call the TTU Oakley STEM Center at 931-372-6573

DeKalb Middle School students peered into the night sky over Smithville Tuesday, despite being inside the old DeKalb Middle School gymnasium in the middle of the day.
Motlow College associate professor and STEM program director Billy Hix set up his 24-foot inflatable planetarium dome center court to give students a tour of the stars.
When students entered the planetarium, the experience simulated moving through the solar system and the universe. Hix controlled the projection inside the dome using special software on a laptop. The software simulates different dates, planets and solar systems.
Inside the dome, students immediately identified the constellations as they appear this time of year.
Superimposing images of Greek mythology over the constellations, Hix then introduced students to the most prominent stars. “Usually on a typical planetarium show, I will address some of the outstanding constellations for the current date and a lesson regarding the Greek stories that helped name the constellations.”
As part of his tour of the night sky Tuesday, Hix zoomed in on Jupiter and its moon, Io. The atmospheric storm known as Jupiter’s great red spot, Hix said, is three times the size of Earth and Jupiter’s moon, Io, is the most geologically active object in the Solar System with more than 400 active volcanoes.
Further zooming in on the pitted face of Io, Hix explained that Jupiter, the largest planet in our solar system, has such an immense gravitational pull on Io that “it’s pulling its guts out.”
“Soon,” Hix said, Io will fall apart and form rings around Jupiter. However, “soon” is a relative term to astronomers. “Anything less than a million years,” he explained.
Hix also told the students how that our earth’s sun is dying and Saturn’s rings are disappearing.
Hix made his first STEM presentation in 1986 and added the planetarium about three years ago. Since that time, his nationally recognized program has traveled more than 5,000 miles to bring astronomy to more than 12,000 students in more than 140 schools.
“We target schools that are challenged by their students’ social economic makeup,” said Hix. “Due to that, I am honored to be the first person that takes them on a visit to a real planetarium and it is up to me to open their eyes to a much larger universe.”
“The planetarium is used to hopefully stimulate an excitement about learning in general, and even more so with regards to science or STEM areas.”
Hix, who has worked as an astronomer for NASA, said his passion for visiting schools to teach about space began back when he was in elementary school. “When I was in the fifth grade, we were about to land on the moon, and I was nuts about learning about space, stars, and the space program,” said Hix. “At my little four-room country school no one else was interested and I wanted someone to speak to us about space.”
The lack of space education in his youth drove Hix to reach out to others. “Well, my teacher told me that we were going to have a speaker, but the speaker was from CO-OP and he talked about fertilizer,” added Hix. “I told my mom that I was going to visit schools and find people just like me, and we were going to learn about the space program.”
Inspired by his experience as a student who was raised in a rural area, Hix desires to teach students who might not otherwise have any exposure to astronomy.
“I work hard to make sure to visit schools that are rural and higher poverty, but I will visit any school as I see myself as a hungry-to-learn little lad when I visit,” he continued. “It is a passion that I have to share science and the night sky with our youth.”
In February 2014, the American Astronomical Society awarded Hix with their Master Outreach Award, an award that is given to an individual who has made a difference in the understanding of astronomy science across the nation.

A Smithville man has been indicted by the Grand Jury in a rash of recent forgeries for passing stolen checks to an individual and at three local businesses.
22 year old Enrique (Ricky) Adelaido Lomas of Bright Hill Road, Smithville was indicted Monday for eight counts of forgery and one count of theft of property under $500. The cases were investigated by a Sheriff’s Department Detective.
He will be arraigned in DeKalb County Criminal Court on Monday, December 7.
Sheriff Patrick Ray said that on Monday, July 6 Lomas stole a check from the glove box of a truck. He was charged with theft in that case.
Lomas then passed forged checks to another individual for $150 on Tuesday, July 7 and for $130 on Friday, July 10. In at least one case, white out was used as Lomas changed the amount of the check.
Meanwhile on Thursday, July 16, Lomas passed forged checks in amounts of $120 and $80 at Kwik N Ezy.
Five days later on Tuesday, July 21 Lomas passed forged checks in amounts of $100 & $65 to Discotienda Latina, $100 to Kwik N Ezy and $100 to Mercadito Chabelita
In some cases the checks were flagged as stolen and returned to the merchants.

The DeKalb County Grand Jury indicted 37 people Monday including three who were named in sealed indictments.
Arraignment for each defendant is set for Monday, December 7 at 9:00 a.m. in DeKalb County Criminal Court.
Those indicted and their charges are as follows:
Joshua Lynn Batey: driving on a suspended license and failure to maintain lane, theft under $500 and public intoxication
David Lee Bean: driving under the influence (2nd offense), financial responsibility, failure to maintain lane
Melissa Faye Bean: driving under the influence (2nd offense)
Tommye Lou Bell: driving under the influence and financial responsibility
Shanna Bogle: theft over $1,000
Gary Jason Britt: driving under the influence, reckless endangerment, and failure to maintain lane
B.J. Lee Brown: driving on a suspended license, financial responsibility, child restraint, and speeding
Rebecca Dawn Duffield and James Anthony Skinner: theft over $1,000 and vandalism under $500
Therese Kae Herriott: driving under the influence
Rita Gail Houk: theft under $500 and vandalism under $500
Terry Allen King: possession of a schedule II over 0.5 grams for sale
Amail John Land: burglary, theft under $500, and vandalism under $500
Terra Elaine Locklear and Jessie Eugene Thomas: aggravated burglary, theft over $1,000, and vandalism under $500
Enrique Adelaido Lomas: forgery (8 counts) and theft under $500
Brandi Lynn McPheron: obtaining prescription by fraud (6 counts)
Christopher Brian Pack: driving on a revoked license
Christopher Neil Patterson: violation of restraining order
Kimberly Patterson: possession of schedule II for resale
Gregory Wayne Roberts: driving under the influence (2nd offense) and driving on a revoked license (3rd offense)
Tonya Silcox: driving under the influence and possession of paraphernalia
Genevieve Sonnier: driving under the influence, evading arrest, possession of a schedule IV, and failure to maintain lane
Rickey Clifton Stanley: driving under the influence and seatbelt violation
James Freddie Summers: theft under $500
Ramiro Torres: public intoxication
James Grady Warner, Jr.: aggravated assault and domestic assault
John Wayne Warner: driving under the influence (2nd offense), driving on a revoked license (3rd offense), financial responsibility, and violation of implied consent
Dra Dewayne Watkins: auto burglary (3 counts), theft over $1,000, theft over $500, and theft under $500
Destry Wiggins: indecent exposure
Paul Woodcock, Jr. : auto burglary and theft under $500 (3 counts)
Craig Alan Yarbrough: theft over $1,000 and theft under $500
Michelle Renee Yarbro: driving under the influence, possession of a schedule II and IV for resale, possession of schedule II, and possession of paraphernalia
William Stephen Zaderiko: false report and theft over $1,000

The DeKalb County Democratic Party will host its Annual Holiday Event on Thursday, December 10 at 6:30 p.m. at the DeKalb County High School cafeteria.
Former Mayor Karl Dean of Nashville will be the Keynote speaker. Lenda Sherrell, Hillary for America Tennessee Coordinator, will introduce Mayor Dean. Music for the evening will be provided by Tom Duggin performing Elvis’ Christmas Classics.
Join us for food, fun and music. If you have a special holiday food, feel free to share. If you have any questions, call Jordan Wilkins at 615-464-5440.

A power outage Monday night affected the entire City of Smithville and a great portion of DeKalb County.
According to Richie Knowles of Smithville Electric System, the problem originated from a feeder line to the airport which shorted out causing a breaker at the sub-station on West Main Street to fail. This activated a circuit switcher resulting in the widespread power outage for all customers of Smithville Electric System and customers of Caney Fork Electric Cooperative throughout the county.
The power was later restored for all customers.

Smithville Police Chief Mark Collins was sworn in Monday night at city hall.
With his wife and daughter looking on, Collins took the oath from City Attorney Vester Parsley. Mayor Jimmy Poss was also present along with City Police Commissioner/Alderman Jason Murphy, City Administrator Hunter Hendrixson and members of the police department.

Following the brief ceremony, Chief Collins met with his fellow officers.

The Sheriff’s Department has made an arrest in a recent burglary and theft.
24 year old Brandi Louise Brewer of Barnes Mill Road, charged with burglary and theft of property over $1,000, is under a $25,000 bond and she will be in court on December 10.
Sheriff Patrick Ray said that on or about Monday, November 9 Brewer allegedly broke into a building on South Tittsworth Road and stole two chainsaws, an air compressor, an air tank, two wrench sets, an Impact socket, a socket wrench, a hammer drill, a jigsaw, and a 12 volt drill. The total value of the stolen items comes to $1,374. Some of the goods has been recovered and identified by the property owner.
Meanwhile, 43 year old Travis Fane Reeves of Pine Creek Falls Road, Smithville is charged with domestic assault. His bond is $2,500 and he will make a court appearance on December 10.
Sheriff Ray said that on Monday, November 16 a deputy responded to the emergency room of Saint Thomas DeKalb Hospital to speak with a woman who was injured in an assault by her husband at their home. The woman said Reeves threw boots at her, grabbed her around the neck with his arm, and punched her right thigh with his fist causing bruising. According to the officer, the woman had visible scratches on her neck and left hand. It was determined that Reeves was the primary aggressor and he was placed under arrest.
23 year old Brent J. Bogle and 45 year old Glenda Madonna Bogle both of Young Ridge Road, Sparta are each under a $2,500 bond after being charged in separate assaults on Pine Grove Road last Monday, November 16.
Sheriff Ray said that a deputy, in response to a domestic incident, learned that Brent Bogle had allegedly assaulted his girlfriend’s father. Bogle was determined to have been the primary aggressor in that case and he was arrested for domestic assault.
Glenda Bogle allegedly got in a fight with a woman there hitting the victim in the face with her fist. Bogle was charged with assault.
22 year old Kacy Renee Davenport of High Street, Alexandria is charged with domestic assault. She is under a $2,500 bond and she will make a court appearance on December 10.
Sheriff Ray said that on Thursday, November 19 a deputy was dispatched to a residence on High Street in Alexandria in response to an unwanted guest call. Upon arrival the officer spoke with a woman who said she and her daughter, Davenport had gotten into an argument and that Davenport had thrown milk in her face which resulted in a physical altercation. Davenport allegedly hit her mother leaving a knot on the back of her head. Davenport was placed under arrest.